Idea Dump 2018
As each year passes and my to-do lists get longer, I have to accept that I will die long before I will get to make and do everything I want to.
Here are some things that I probably will never get to, but maybe you will? Don’t let the crackpot-stream-of-consciousness-style throw you, I believe most of these ideas could actually be successful and profitable… with some work.
Let me know if you are truly interested and I will try to share any effort I’ve already invested to give you a head start….
Supercheap backwards-proof coin cell holder
You have to make sure that things will not burst into flames when a user puts in a battery backwards. This typically involves protection diodes or transistors, but these are extra parts, points of failure, and hurt battery life. I’ve seen holders like these that are reverse proof…
…but they are complicated and crazy expensive.
I think you could make a really cheap one out of a single piece of stamped steel that had some little ears on the sides and some strategically applied paint or plastic film on the inside top to prevent the ‘-‘ side of an improperly inserted battery from making contact…
Also see the little finger window so you can easily push the battery out? It is such a pain to wrestle batteries out of the holders I use now.
To get the price right, you would have to make millions of them and get people to use them, which would likely require getting UL to say that they were good enough reverse protection to depend on for certification.
If you make this then I will be your first big order!
Tree-based problem management
When I am working on a problem, I almost always use the same strategy – I think of all the potential solutions to the problem and then start to think about what problems I might have trying to implement those solutions (repeated recursively). It becomes a dependency tree with a problem depending on solutions, which themselves depend on problems, etc.
Let’s say that Solution A depends on solving Problem X and Problem Y. As soon as you discover that Problem X is not viable, then there is no reason to work on Problem Y. You can also give up on any higher up problem that depended on Solution A. Similary you can have solutions that depend on solving Problem X or Problem Y, in which case solving either means you do not have to look at the other or anything below it… and any higher or’s that depend on solution are also completed.
This sounds almost trivial, but for actual hard problems these trees can get very complicated, and it is easy to get lost in trying to solve a sub-problem and forget all the other contingencies on that solution.
I think you could build something like this in JS or even Bubble pretty quickly. It could be totally graphical, and I love the idea of seeing that there is actually one critical problem down towards that bottom of the tree that, once resolved as either solved or not viable, would immediately shrink the problem space in otherwise unexpected ways.
I can’t tell you how much time this would save me, and hopefully promote this problem solving strategy to others.
Skyhook ladder stabilized by reaction wheels
A ladder that you do not need to lean up against anything. Think really tall Segway that you can climb up. So many times I’ve needed this!
You could also make a great straight-up selfie camera pole.
Isolated Wifi base station as a product
This is a Wifi access point that it not connected to the internet. Instead all content is served locally, and it acts as a captive portal to any devices that connect to it.
The poster child use-case would be to put one of these in the middle of big park with no cell coverage. The default splash page would be a map of the park, and it would even show the user where they are on the map using a JS location API to get GPS from the viewer’s phone. You could also see where all the other people connected are (or recently were) and easily send messages to them (either real-time, or store-and-forward, or public bulletin board style). There would be a guest book you could sign and lot of other useful information (remember there is no cell coverage here). Maybe even an SOS button with a back-haul to the ranger station that also uses your location.
For hardware, you could using an existing cheap and robust off-the-shelf outdoor AP (like this) connected to a solar panel and battery sized for the location. There are some tricks you can do to make this super cheap and easy to flat pack too.
Most of the tech for this project is done, it is really about adding polish and making it into a real, supportable product. It would probably would make sense to start as a kickstarter. I think there are so many people who could use this for cool stuff.
And I’ve left (I think!) the best part for last…. I think there is a trick we could use to let people use this completely isolated AP to actually get messages out to the internet – albeit with an indeterminate delay. On the AP we send people to a real domain and make it look like we are really at the right IP address with our embedded DNS server. We use the real certs for the local website, so as far as the phone can tell they are really connected to the real deal so it is happy to accept cookies from us. Inside these cookies we store compressed and encrypted outbound messages. Now when that phone eventually gets back to civilization and goes to the internet connected server at the same domain we were faking, it dumps these cookies up to the server. The server decodes and forwards them on their way. The server can also drop some cookies to let the isolated server know that the messages got passed just in case that phone ever goes back to the park. We’d also possibly get a back-channel if people who are planning a trip to the park went to the internet-connected website before they left.
Make a building that (seems like) you can move it
You know optical illusions? This is more of a touch feedback illusion.
I once just happened to bump hard into the sink in my bathroom at the exact moment that the toilet tank rocked because it was done filling. The effect was powerful- my brain was certain that my bumping the sink had shook the whole building. It took several seconds for me to figure out what had actually happened, during which time I was wonderfully bewildered.
It would be easy to set up a room where things would be able to detect when they were bumped. Hard bumps would use actuators to cause other movable objects to react as if the building had shifted.
If this was on a high floor of a tall building, I think it could be a compelling tourist attraction. I’d sure pay to have that feeling again!
Hand of god
Roller coaster meets skydiving meets white water rafting down the grand canyon.
I’ve been dreaming of jumping off the top of the Grace Building since I was a little kid. It always seemed like the curve would catch me like the hand of god.
I’ve love to build a giant stainless steel parabolic curve. Really giant, like hundreds of feet tall. The curve would be vertical at the top, gently becoming horizontal by the bottom. It would “catch” you by directing your downward motion into forward motion. At the top you would be in free-fall, at the bottom you’d be on the fastest county fair slide ever.
The joints of the panels would be stainless steel and lapped like roof shingles so there was nothing you could get caught on. Everyone would wear a full coverage Tyvek suit and a motorcycle helmet so no part of you would ever touch the surface.
Ideally, you would want to build this against the face of an existing cliff. It would be wide enough that lots of people could all use it at the same time (not narrow like a slide).
At the top, you would run as fast as you wanted to towards the edge… and jump off into oblivion.
Besides the thrill of repeatedly jumping off a cliff without a para-shoot, I think this monumental gleaming mirrored curve in the middle of a landscape would be a thrilling spectacle just to look at!
For whom the bell tolls
Public art project.
The Rabble Rain Room
Rain Room is cool, but not worth $40.
Let’s make a rain room for the rest of us! And make it better (bigger,denser, more responsive, silent except for the rain) than the real one!
Use electrostatic valves with no moving parts to make the super cheapo rain headers. Use direct laser breaks to sense where the people are (know what you are thinking, but you are wrong). Get a trash pump and some PVC and bob’s your uncle.
This one is basically done, you just need to set it up someplace and tell people where to come!
Electrostaticly accelerated abrasive cutting
Water jet cutters use water to accelerate and carry the abrasive to the workpeice, but it is messy and imprecise. Instead, electrostaticly accelerate a stream of abrasive particles directly. You would likely need to be be in a soft vacuum, but the payoff is an extremely thin and accurate kerf- almost as thin as the individual particles. Kinetic energy at impact is almost unlimited, and you could use a multi-stage barrel like in rail guns to avoid super high voltages.
Potential nice side effect- charged abrasive particles repel each other so maybe an easy way to have uniform dispersion and declumping.
Back scratching machine
Why don’t we have a machine for the one thing we can’t do for ourselves?!
The tech is easy, but this would take some serious (but pleasant!) R&D to really nail what pressures, tip types, and motions make for a great back scratch – and it is likely you could ultimately produce an experience that was, at least sensually, better than any human backscratcher.
Great kickstarter, and ultimately would be a long returning product.
CNC in an Altoids Tin
Make a CNC machine that used EDM to remove the metal.
The conductive blank would be immersed in de-ionized water inside the bottom of the tin and the tip of a hypodermic needle would trace out the “cuts’. Continuous flow though the needle would wash away the spoils. Careful control of the needle height would make for thin kerfs. The needle could be automatically electrochemicaly sharpened periodically.
Since there are almost no forces on the tip, the actuators can be tiny. It would be slow, but who cares – leave it running all night.
This would be a home run kickstarter, especially if one of the demo projects was someone who made their own mechanical watch on it.
EDM PCB cutter
I have an OtherMill for making printed circuit boards, but the accuracy and minimum kerf size limits its use.
Use EDM like in the above project with a very pointy hypodermic needle. Super slow, so only suitable for Voronoi and isolation paths, but oh the accuracy and tiny feature sizes you could do! OMG, the RF circuits you could make!
For sure there is only a limited market for this, but I PROMISE that you’d sell at lest one… to me! Maybe Bre will buy your company too. :)
Consumer desktop wire bonding machine
Once you have an EDM PCB cutter, you’ll quickly loose patience with all those giant SMD packages. WLCSP all the way baby, but how? Flip them on their backs and wirebond them directly to the board! I have a wire bonding machine and I can’t imagine how anyone lives with out one… except that they are huge and cost so much. But they don’t have to. I bet you could make a consumer grade one for a couple hundred bucks if you put a little time and effort into it. The tips (“tools”) are a commodity, and the rest is just a lot of low tech stuff that has not been optimized in decades.
Electrolysis desktop fireplace
An ever-burning, sealed combustion, electrically powered real flame.
Start with a small hermetically sealed glass chamber filled with ionized water. An induction coupling powers some long lasting electrodes to generate Brown’s gas, which is collected and artfully conducted to a combustion area. The atmosphere inside should include something to “soot” and make the flame glow with the traditional oranges and yellow (plain hydrogen flame does not look like a fireplace fire)? The condensate is discretely collected out of sight and infinitely recycled.
The tech here is important, but the design and form factor will make or break this as a product. It really needs to be gorgeous.
Oh, and keep it small to make sure there is never too much H2 in there! Wow that stuff blows up good!
Perfect Kickstarter home run if done and sold artfully.
Not practical for home use, but cool…
Building a Wireless Power Plasma Candle ( Flame Discharge ft. Teslaundmehr)
Low cost microfilm service
There are lots of ways to back up data efficiently and cheaply, but all require that you have a computer to access the restored data.
Make a service where users upload a bunch of PDFs and then they get one of these in the mail…
Sure it is a novelty, but also could be actually useful. Come on, I bet you have 20 pages of documents that you’d want in your pocket when a zombie apocalypse (or EMP pulse?) hits, right?
This is mostly about setting up the website and marketing, making the actual films is 50’s tech. I’ve even been able to fit a page of text into a 1mm square by just pointing my old skool Nikon FE2 at a monitor on the other side of a dark room, and I haven’t even tried the good stuff yet.
But maybe once you get some traction, it turns out that there is a real market for no-computer-needed high density backups. Really. Then you get to buy one of these and offer 0.000283465 point text output! :)
The always awesome Ben Krasnow is all over this. I bet he is working towards making lithography masks…
BTW, I have since gotten an old school film recorder which is very cool and I bet I could get >10K lines out of it using an Arduino to control the CRT.
Contemporaneously transcribe everything you say and hear. Search for things in your conversations as easily as you search for things in emails.
Thanks to all kinds of laws, you just can’t go around recording stuff. You’ll eventually go to jail. Thanks Nixon.
But it seems that there are no laws against contemporaneously transcribing everything.
I’ve been working on this for 20 years, but the tech to make it really work has finally arrived. As of like yesterday, this is now almost trivial to do.
I got pretty far in the past. I actually have a legal opinion that this is kosher. I also have lots of geeky equipment… that is likely no longer necessary (just use Bluetooth headphones or leave your phone in your breast pocket). I even have the domain ready when you are.
Electrostatically driven heat pump windows
Fill the sealed space in between window panes with a permanently ionized gas.
Electrostatically make the gas oscillate between the two panes such that it is alternately compressed against one pane and then allowed to expand out towards the other.
The glass on the compression side gets a little warmer, the other side gets a little colder. You have an efficient heat pump with no moving parts and lots of surface area, exactly where you want to sink and source heat – at the building envelope.
Maybe coat the panes with ITO to make it work. You’d need a layer of insulation between the ITO and the gas to keep it from deionizing, so maybe a thin film dielectric on top. Heck, you are depositing low E films on the window anyway, right?
If it turns out to be hard to keep an isolated gas ionized for a long time (is it? Please tell me!) you could maybe put a catalyst in there to make more ions with solar energy, or just use an old skool a pointy electrode.
Bounce the gas at resonant frequency for best efficiency. Pick a gas and a chamber width to be sub-audible or ultrasonic otherwise you’ve just made an awful one of these.
High efficiency inverter window AC unit
These days you can get the most amazingly well designed and built ductless mini split heat pump systems. They use inverters to run the compressor to exactly meet the load. The compressor is soooo quiet – and it is outside where you wont hear it anyway. The inside fan coil is nearly silent.
But, alas, the smallest one is too big for NYC apartment dwellers- and a few billion other urbanizes in hot cities around the world.
Basically take a minisplit and shrink it down to fit in a window. Have separate fans so the only stuff that runs between inside to outside are the two refrigerant lines and a condensate drain. These pipes are only 1″ high so you can run them in a flat pan. Hey, now you can close the window almost all the way with the AC installed! Now you really can’t hear the (already very quiet) compressor outside.
Mount the compressor BELOW the sill so it does not block the view of the outside. This also makes is possible to use gravity to drip the condensate down onto the condenser coils. Remember that water is cold and wet, so the coils run so much better- ask any giant facility that sprays water on their chiller coils. But condensate has no dissolved minerals, so it cleans the coils rather than leaving scale.
There are many other tricks you can add when you decide that you care about quality, quiet, and efficient rather than first cost. There are lots of expensive AC window units out there, but they are all expensive for the wrong reasons (bluetooth AC? Really?). As far as I can tell, there are not any GOOD window units. I have a felling there is a big untapped market here (I know I want one!).
I so want to buy ones of these, but now I live in a place with no windows to put it in!
Bedtime now, so this will have to be enough ideas to get you started.
Good? Bad? Impossible? Already been done?
Please let me know in the comments below!
Also feel free to ask for more details if you are interested.
A strategy for bootstrapping the Rabble Rain Room… Start luxury and move down market. Mimicking Tesla’s strategy of starting with the Roadster.
Become the next must-have design fixture for luxury boutiques, hotels, and homes. You’re nothing unless you have a “rain room” entranceway!
Partner with a company like Bocci. Who’s 14 Series chandelier (https://www.bocci.ca/14-series/) can be seen gracing showrooms, lobbies, and private dining rooms in all the world’s most expensive properties. They provide the cachet; you provide the technology.
Invest the proceeds into creating the “rain room for the rest of us” public facilities. Which would provide for idea generation and quality assurance for the next generation of luxury fixtures (in addition to the enjoyment factor, and stream of recurring revenue).
And a tangential idea… parts of each rain room public facility could be cordoned off and marketed as a focus area. Many people listen to ambient sounds of rain on their headphones while attempting focused work to block out the world of distractions. The rain room focus areas would provide for complete physical and mental isolation for periods of thought in an environment with surreal ambiance. I would totally pay for this!
Ha! I was not even thinking of the Rabble Rain Room as a consumer product – I imagined it as an travelling road attraction!
Get a 1995 Sprinter on craigslist and load it up with your Rain Room rigging. Drive into a new town and set up in the nearest abandoned parking lot or high school gymnasium. Keep collecting $10 a head until you run out of Sneeches, and then move on. I will totally shotgun for at least the first few stops!
If I was going to do anything with Bocci, it would be the #14-continuous electric flame version! That could actually be so beautiful with the ionized water in the bottom of each hanging vessel leading up to a glass blown flute topped with an actual living flame. Tell them to call me and lets make this happen! :)
An isolated wifi access point just hit Kickstarter here!
Looks like an interesting product that will be useful to lots of people if they ship it. Different form what I’d make in…
They added one of these so it can get out over satellite. This increases the cost significantly, but could be worth it for some applications. I’d rather make something that costs like $100 and has no recurring fees.
They want to you pack your own in and out. I’d rather have a fixed one that everyone in a given area uses.
They run on battery. I’d rather run off an embedded solar panel so it is set and forget.
So you won’t feel isolated in the wilderness anymore.. What good is that!?
But then they put the following testimonial on their page: “I sleep so much better hearing from him before bed. – MOM”.
In your wifi AP idea: “We use the real certs for the local website, so as far as the phone can tell they are really connected to the real deal.”
You didn’t just successfully spoof certificates but now you can hack into every website, bank and the blockchain and are very very rich.
On a serious note.. I like the idea of a secluded AP.. feels like a quiet island. Maybe you can interact with the other people there too, away from the crowds of the real internet!
No spoofing needed!
To clarify, the isolated WAP would redirect to a domain that I control, so I would have the cert for it. So, for example, if I were setting one up on top of my hill I might register joshhill.com and get a cert for it. I’d then put the private key for this cert on the WAP and on a separate normal internet connected webserver. A device connecting to the WAP will see the webpages as properly signed and happily accept any cookies. Then later when it is back connected to the real internet, it will again connect to joshhill.com, but this time it is actually connecting to the normal webserver – but it sees the same cert so happily send up any cookies that the WAP put there.
Yeah that’s quite possible.. but people would have to enter joshhill.com (or redirected). I though you were saying that people just enter, say wp.josh.com, and they see wp.josh.com, which is impossible.
Even with joshhill.com, entering a TLS (https) connection would be a pain because the device likely won’t have the security certificate of your website right away and would need traversing the chain-of-trust to verify the certificate, which you’ll have to (correctly and authentically) spoof on your wifi until they can reach a certificate they already have on their device, at which point the device will form a connection.. or you can simply use http.
Use a cheap logic-level FET like the AO3400 for reverse battery protection. They are about 1c ea in quantities over 100.
Click to access slva139.pdf
If you want to get more sophisticated, you can use a protection circuit like the RPi:
I did not know about the RaspPi protection circuit. Thoughtful design!
FETs do work fine and are the standard solution, but have a few downsides I wish I could avoid.
For very low power applications (I am working on something now that has a 1uA power budget!) , it sucks to pay the cost of the gate leakage current 24×7 for decades to guard against an event that happens once or twice in the product’s lifetime.
For higher power applications, the RDSon becomes significant, and again I hate to pay for that extra voltage drop continuously the entire time the device is working.
For low voltage applications, the minimum turn on voltage of the FET can limit how low you can drain down the battery. The AO3400 essentially turns off below 2 volts, and some of my circuits could otherwise ride all the way down to 1.8V.
While you will correctly argue that you can tailor the device selection to minimize either of these cases, that are times when you have a product that sleeps almost all the time at very low quiescent current draw, and then wakes to use high current.
There are also additional costs to using any extra part beyond the per-unit price. That part has to be sourced, shipped, and kept in inventory. The extra part uses precious PCB area and the extra traces are in the direct power path so there is EMI to consider. The part uses up a slot in the pick-and-place machine, which is potentially VERY expensive if this bumps you up to the next machine.
There are certainly valid defenses to all of these, but taken in whole I think it would be nice to be able to solve the problem wholesale with a slight modification to a hunk of metal part that you have to use anyway!
In the meantime, I am always looking for better ideas for the very low power use case. Got any reverse protection part/circuit suggestions for maximum battery utilization with a load on the order of 1uA that can run down to 1.8V?
Unless I’m reading the datasheet wrong, FET gate leakage is in the nanoamp range, well below the self-discharge rate of a CR2032.
I also think trying to use a lithium coin cell below 2.5V is an exercise in futility. Below 2.5V, the internal resistance goes way up, and there is minimal capacity left. You can see this in Energizer’s datasheet. If you use cheap generic coin cells, the IR is even worse.
Click to access cr2032.pdf
Your comment about the gate leakage has me wondering just how significant it would be. I don’t have any equipment good enough to measure nA, but I’m thinking a high efficiency blue LED in series with a 5V supply and no load on the FET could give a rough idea of the leakage current. In my testing, they are visible below 100nA. If the LED is not visible in the dark, that would suggest a leakage current below 10nA.
Your isolated Wifi base station sounds a bit like https://piratebox.cc/
Your isolated Wifi base station sounds a bit like https://piratebox.cc/
Brilliant idea with the OrsonEar!
One question I have is, what is the next step for a person who is potentially interested in taking this forward?
I think next step for OrsonEar would be to build a working prototype with the latest tech. It would probably use one of the awesome new low-power ARM chips and an optimized recognition engine. Remember that this is unlike normal speech recognition applications because you just need to encode a short-hand like phonetic system rather than disambiguating homonyms.
The hardware might look something like the SenseTone is supposed to look (it doesn’t seem to exist yet).
I’d also seek a proper legal option letter outlining the requirements to ensure that an OrsonEar transcription would not be considered recording for legal purposes. When in the spectrum from wave file to text file does a stream of bytes representing what someone said turn from a recording into a transcription? LMK when you get the answer! :)
Different message than mine, but we do now have bells along the NYC water waterfront public art!…
UPDATE RE ROBOT BACK MASSAGE:
UPDATE RE EFFICIENT WINDOW AC UNITS:
Much has happened in this space. Except for some technical points, the Gradient is basically what I was thinking…
UPDATE RE DESKTOP EDM:
They did not take advantage of the fact that EDM has almost zero forces, which makes the machine bulky and less precise, but a good move in the right direction for at least 2D work…